Several years ago I published to the world The Perfect College Football Playoff System. Since that time the NCAA has taken a few baby steps in that direction. But this change has not been enough, and this year supplies a pretty good example of the inadaquacy of the current system. The example is Western Michigan.
The Western Michigan Broncos have had an undefeated season, winning most of their games in blowout fashion. Their non-conference schedule included two road games against Big 10 opponents, which they of course won. Is Western Michigan national championship caliber? We will never really know, since they are not even in the discussion of the current playoff system. Why not? Simply because they do not have the tradition behind them.
The perfect college playoff system would remedy this injustice easy as pie, and should be implemented immediately. I will offer my services to the NCAA to oversee the transition for a fee. To summarize the perfect system:
- All conference champions are in (currently 10 teams)
- Top six ranked non-champions are in (total of 16 teams)
- Teams seeded 1-16, with 1 playing 16, 2 playing 15 etc.
- In first round, highest seeded team is home team.
- Subsequent rounds are at neutral sites similar to bowl games.
This year the perfect system would look like this:
Appalachian St. @ Alabama
Western Kentucky @ Clemson
San Diego St. @ Ohio St.
Temple @ Washington
Western Michigan @ Penn St.
Florida St. @ Michigan
Colorada @ Oklahoma
USC @ Wisconsin
As you can see, the Big 10 is well represented this year. Second round games would be paired by a committee. Games could match up a Rose Bowl type matchup with Ohio St. and Washington. Or an Alabama and Clemson Cotton Bowl. Regional considerations could be made for a Michigan and Wisconsin game. Such neutral site bowl games would funnel down quickly to a national championship game. This is the perfect system.
Typical irrelevant objections include that this would result in to many games. Hogwash. These teams would be playing bowl games anyway, and you could easily remove a regular season game if it was that important. With this simple adjustment, it would only result in extra games for 4 teams. And the best part is that this year, an undefeated team like Western Michigan gets a chance to show what they can do.